Dr. Terry Olson, Professor in the School of Family Life at BYU, writes, "Very few things frustrate parents more than having their children lie to them. This is partly because parents whose children lie often feel that they have "failed."" (17).
Many children lie at some point. Dr. Olson goes on to say, "Too often, parents condemn themselves unnecessarily," and then he gives great counsel for what parents can do who find themselves facing this problem.
"Often a parent's first impulse when he suspects a lie is to say, "I know you're lying! Now tell me the truth!" The trouble with accusing a child of lying is that you're practically inviting him to tell another lie. Why? Because if he's lying to protect his image of himself, and a parent puts on more pressure, he's going to protect himself even more "and the lie grows" (Olson 17).
Dr. Olson shares a story about a time his six-year-old daughter began to say she was completing her reading when she was not.
Looking for the Cause
Because lying often has an underlying emotional cause such as avoiding punishment or may be used to build up oneself when there are deep feelings of inadequacy, you can see that resorting to teaching the morality of lying may not be the best first step.
An Increase of Love
"There is a handbook of human relations in the Doctrine and Covenants, section 121. In verse 43 the Lord says that when we rebuke someone when moved upon by the Holy Ghost, we must be sure afterwards to show forth an increase of love.
Lying is one way to attempt to avoid the effects of punishment. As you observe your child beginning to lie about his responsibility for certain actions, it may be a good time to assess whether avoiding unwanted or even inappropriate consequences may be the issue.
Model honest behavior. Go out of your way to model the importance of honesty. Be alert to times when you are tempted to be dishonest, as in speaking disparagingly of someone in private but acting differently in their presence, or asking a child to tell someone on the phone that you are not home.
Dr. Olson teaches that sometimes children feel they have to be exceptional to earn their parents' praise. However, if we tune into the small stuff, like a made bed or completed homework assignment, our children are less likely to try and gain our attention by stretching the truth about their accomplishments.
Point out examples of honesty all around you. Talk about the good people at the grocery store who wait to pay for items, the prophets in the Book of Mormon who set good examples, and "most important," talk about examples of honesty "from the lives of personal friends and relatives" (Olson 18).
Our children may express themselves in ways in which fantasy and reality are mixed up. These innocent manifestations of untruths may be harmless and need not be a worry.
"When kids do tell the truth, Love and Logic parents respond with support. We must say, "Thank you for being honest. I'm sure it was hard for you to tell me that. I bet it was hard on you to know you made that mistake. That is really sad." Then we drop the issue" (Cline and Fay 199). If restitution needs to be made, support your child as he goes through those steps.
"If you don't have any evidence that your child is lying, just vague feelings that something isn't quite right, that something is being hidden, then any accusations you might make will probably do more damage than good. Whether your child is lying or not, accusations or doubts will cause him to feel that you don't believe what he says and may cause a breakdown in communication. One of the positive things you should do at that point is work to strengthen your relationship with your child. Making him feel loved, accepted, and respected by making communication easy and comfortable will go a long way toward helping the child overcome his fears and talk frankly with you" (Olson 18).
Teach the importance of honesty in formal and informal ways. Whether or not lying is an issue in your family, discuss and demonstrate the benefits of honesty in their relationships inside and outside the family. You could talk about how society can't function without honest people, etc.
"The truth shall make you free," the Savior said (John 8:32). When parents help their children see that the truth frees them of anxiety, of unneeded guilt, or having to hide things from the people they love, such parents will be well along the road to teaching their children to "walk uprightly before the Lord" (D&C 68:28), (Olson 20).
Cline, Foster and Jim Fay. Parenting with Love and Logic. USA: Pinion Press, 2006.
Olson, Terry. "When Your Children Lie to You," Ensign. Aug. 1977: 17.